[s-cars] also starting to consider other awd sedans
Wayne Dohnal
wd1 at hevanet.com
Thu Dec 9 17:05:45 EST 2004
> How about a Subaru Legacy GT? Rumor has it that next year they're
> bringing it over with a high revving 2.0L turbo or even a variation of
> the STi 2.5L turbo motor
As the owner of a 1995 Legacy since it was new, let me chime in on this.
First disclaimer: I'm not judging performance. My '95 2.2 is a slug.
Second disclaimer: Maybe they've changed a lot, but when I test drove a new
'02 they were sitll the same as mine.
The Subaru is a good put-put for short trips, but it's hard to even compare
it with an Audi because it's like apples and oranges. The solid feeling
just isn't there. The comfort isn't there. After 30 minutes in the Subaru
I have the same fatigue as with 4 hours in the Audi. It's just the
individual things like road noise and seat comfort that all add up. I
usually have a free choice of which car to use, and if the trip is over a
few miles I never choose the Subaru.
The positive thing for the Subaru is that you can kick it around and it
still keeps going. In 10 years and over 100K miles the only major problem
was a horrendously leaky front crank seal. It took less work to replace the
seal and the timing belt that it takes to get the Audi's front end taken
apart just to get started on the engine. I've spent less on parts for the
Subaru in 10 years that I spend every year for the Audi. But I like the
Audi better. It's not even a close choice.
Wayne Dohnal
1994 S4
More information about the S-CAR-List
mailing list