[urq] Toyota UA debacle

[Mike Del Tergo]

Scott,

nowhere did I read that part of your reaction was to hit the brakes. If you did, are you saying the car still marched to 90 from 60MPH? That would certainly throw cold water on my belief of brakes being "stronger" than the engine at full tilt.  I had my throttle stick on the V8 last spring, but not at WFO.  It stuck at the speed I was driving about 45 in moderate 2 lane divided hwy traffic.  In that scenario the UFOs did a fine job of modulating my speed till I could pull off in a mile or so and negotiate a small bit of surface roads to pull over and investigate.  Lucky for me the situation never escalated to a need to kill the engine, neutral and brakes got me through.

I'll try and reserve my opinions on what happened with the majority of the Toyota incidents until I see more info.  What I will opine on is the Lady Lexus owners testimony before congress from her incident 3? years ago.  She recounted how she put both feet on the brake pedal to no effect, (I'll have to give her that one given your report) she mentioned shifting into other gears ,N, R (se did not mention P) with no effect, (that surprises me quite a bit and points to multiple system failures), but she also tearfully recounts how she had the time or presence of mind and bluetoothed her husband, but nowhere did she mention turning the car off.  While I have little doubt that she is being truthful as she recalls events, my experiences with dozens of motor vehicles that drive on the road, and more that a few that fly and pilot waterways I have never experienced  a mulitple system failure (thankfully) as she described, from a "consumer" oriented vehicle.

 


From: qshipq at aol.com
Subject: Re: [urq] Toyota UA debacle
To: benswann at verizon.net, quattro at audifans.com, urq at audifans.com
Cc: rmwoodbury at roadrunner.com

 
I don't believe for a second that braking can 'overcome' an engine at WOT, and certainly that would require a 'speed' parameter (including the fade variable spoken to here). And, having experienced a WOT stick in a 4.2 v8 (stuck cruise control rod) 2 years ago, blaming a driver for not being able to react is premature. In my case, the almost WOT to 60, lifting to find none... The next few seconds to 'react' took me to 90+ before I was able to shift to neutral and cut the power. Processing all that, and taking the risk that the ignition cut too far might lock up the wheel, was quite high stress for me. And one of the scariest 20 total seconds of my life. Doing that in traffic? I back up from the driver....
 
 
 		 	   		  
_________________________________________________________________
Hotmail: Free, trusted and rich email service.
http://clk.atdmt.com/GBL/go/201469228/direct/01/