Ugly new A4
Matt Suffern
msuffern at lycos.com
Mon Sep 20 12:03:01 EDT 2004
Agreed. As written on the NCAudi boards:
"There isn't a cohesive sense about the styling. It's almost as if whoever was in charge of designing the nose of the car didn't really compare notes with
whoever designed the sides and back. I agree with the comment made that it's a very Japanese look. Something that always made Audis stand out in
spite of their lack of external ornamentation was the emphasis on proportion over decoration. As an industrial designer that's something I always greatly
admired about them. With the B7, I think they're losing that emphasis.
"The silver lining is that Audi's styling seems to come around again every couple of model cycles, so perhaps the B8 will return to the good old Audi
styling trademarks like stance, class, and taste.
"As far as modern (A4-on) Audi styling is concerned, the B5s were the most iconic of the whole B-series lineage (with the exception of the UrQ, which
doesn't really count). The B6's styling built on the foundations the B5 established as far as proportion and distribution of visual masses. At that point Audi
still hadn't strayed into the realm of decoration over proportion: If you look at the B6's headlights, or grille, or taillights, they're not terribly flashy in and of
themselves--but they serve the cohesive look of the car, emphasizing the overall lines. This is what makes (made? *sigh*) Audis so aggresive-looking
and yet understated. There was something about them that just looked badass but it wasn't an easy-to-pinpoint detail like a headlight or a grille. It was
the proportions, something the majority of the car-buying public doesn't notice on a conscious level--witness the popularity of older Pontiacs, or wings
and mufflers with the ricer crowd. People tend to go for tarted-up crap like that because the details make it look flashy, totally ignoring the fact that the
proportions scream "economy car," and always will, no matter what they put on the outside.
"And sadly, at least with the B7, it looks like Audi's given in and gone the 'decoration' route." :(
Matt
Chapel Hill, NC
'86 4kq
'72 240Z
'88 1JZ Supra (sold!)
More information about the quattro
mailing list