Bearing question

[Bernard Littau]

> > I'm thinking it is unlikely you can build one of these for a front
> > wheel bearing removal out of plumbing and low grade parts.  In my
> > experience, the bushings almost fall out and only need a good nudge.
> > The front wheel bearings on my 5ktq took almost everything my 20 ton
> > shop press had to offer.
> 
> That may be, but the Hub Shark and other tools manage to work.
> It may be worth $20 for better-than-low-grade parts for someone
> who has more time than money to give it a try.
> 
> Just a suggestion, not a guarantee.

I did not mean to imply the real tools for doing the bearing change in
place were not likely to work.  I assume they are made of better grade
materials than plumbing iron :-)  I've not personally used any of
these in-place bearing tools, but people I trust swear by them.

My call was to spend $150 on a 20 ton press, which is more generally
useful than a hub shark at $300.  I did, however have all the other
things you would need to press in and out the bearings except one
piece, which my Dad was able to make out of aluminum on his lathe and
mail to me.  You might be money ahead, and certainly frustration
ahead, by going with the hub shark.

As far as is it worth it to try and build one, I would caution anyone
trying: metal not up to the stresses involved could explode on you. 
Granted, not likely; you are more likely to simply strip a threaded
piece, or stretch something, all without undo drama.  Just be careful
and wear safety goggles.

Best,

Bernard Littau
Woodinville, WA