[Vwdiesel] Unenvironmental Diesels?

Roger Brown r.c.brown at ieee.org
Wed Jun 23 13:58:50 EDT 2004


gary wrote:
> 
> Don't let the anti-diesel crowd fool you.
> 
> Take a look at this (this is one report of many)
> 
> http://mutage.oupjournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/18/5/429
> 
> In short, in a g/km weighting, gas and diesels produce equal amounts of
> carcinogens. However, the report says that diesel indeed produced more
> particles than gasoline, but DNA Binding of gasoline particle-bound PAH
> components were more pronounced than diesel.
> 
> Gasoline particles are smaller in size than diesel, and are able to
> travel deeper into the lungs.
> 
> Hopefully in 2006, the EPA mandate of low sulfur diesel will reduce PM
> emissions of diesels significantly.

I like some of the California (CARB) particulate data:
	http://www.arb.ca.gov/aqd/oldpm10/a2bmd97.htm

Most of the highest PM10 levels occur where?  In the deserts (blowing
dust, especially in the Owens Valley where LA has siphoned off all the
surface water) and the mountains (darn pine trees and the haze they
produce).  I guess reducing the added particulates from diesel and
gasoline is a good thing, but particulates won't be eliminated.

-- 
   Roger


More information about the Vwdiesel mailing list